“Why Didn’t They Ask Evans?” is the newest original series from Britbox, combining everything we love about comic mystery romance with an old-fashioned touch. Adapted from Agatha Christie’s 1934 novel, this series stands out by being lively and fun, unlike some darker Christie adaptations like “Death on the Nile.”
Directed by Hugh Laurie, famous for his role in “House,” the show features sharp dialogue and engaging chemistry between the leads. The story starts with Bobby Jones, a young man in a quaint Welsh town, who finds a dying man at the bottom of a cliff while looking for a lost golf ball. The dying man’s last words, “why didn’t they ask Evans?” become the central mystery. Bobby discovers a photo of a beautiful woman in the dead man’s pocket, leading him into a web of intrigue and danger.
Soon, strange and suspicious characters start showing up in town, and Bobby, along with his adventurous friend, Lady Frankie Derwent, must solve the puzzle. The series follows these amateur detectives through a mix of excitement, danger, and conspiracy, all while they can only trust each other.
The cast is led by Will Poulter as Bobby and Lucy Boynton as Lady Frances, also known as Frankie. Hugh Laurie plays Dr. James Nicholson, with an ensemble including Jonathan Jules, Conleth Hill, Maeve Dermody, and many prominent actors.
Different from many other Agatha Christie stories, this series highlights the romance between Bobby and Frankie. Hugh Laurie’s direction gives it a feel reminiscent of a classic screwball comedy. Although the mystery remains central, it is the charming interplay between Bobby and Frankie that captures the audience.
Lucy Boynton’s portrayal of Frankie is especially noteworthy; she brings a clever and flirtatious energy to the role, making you root for her romantic success with Bobby. The series also remains faithful to the original book, unlike some other adaptations that take creative liberties.
Overall, “Why Didn’t They Ask Evans?” is a delightful mix of romance, mystery, wit, and a beautiful setting. It didn’t get much press, but it’s definitely worth watching. Featuring memorable cameos by Emma Thompson and Jim Broadbent, and with Hugh Laurie playing a significant role, it’s a treat for fans of Agatha Christie.
If you love romantic mysteries, this series will be right up your alley. It’s a perfect blend of crime-solving and romance, with a nod to 1930s screwball comedy and a bit of Jane Austen charm. Let’s hope Hugh Laurie gives us more period drama mysteries in the future.
Content Note: The series is rated TV-MA for occasional strong language and brief violence but overall feels more like a TV-14 show.
“Why Didn’t They Ask Evans?” is available to stream on Britbox or the Britbox Amazon Channel. The series consists of three hour-long episodes.
