I’ve always been fascinated by paranormal romance movies and TV shows. Maybe it goes back to my childhood, re-reading L.J. Smith’s The Secret Circle, or my love for Dark Romanticism and Gothic tales with Byronic monsters. Over time, I’ve noticed that while there is plenty of talk about paranormal romance and urban fantasy books, the discussions rarely extend to the movies and shows, despite their popularity.
That’s where I step in! I’ve compiled a well-researched list of the best paranormal romance movies and shows currently available on Amazon Prime.
Paranormal romance can involve all sorts of supernatural elements like witches, vampires, ghosts, werewolves, psychics, magic, mythological creatures, superhuman abilities, fairies, immortals, and even time travel. For this list, I’ve also included urban fantasy since it’s closely related. Typically, urban fantasy features an urban setting, crime, and elements of paranormal romance.
For a deeper dive into paranormal romance, check out my other list: 150 of the Best Gothic & Paranormal Romance Period Dramas. Some of the choices here are pure paranormal romance, while others have significant paranormal romantic subplots.
Note: The titles listed were available on Amazon Prime in the US as of November 2018 and are subject to change.
50 Best Paranormal Romance Movies & TV Shows on Amazon Prime
1. The 10th Kingdom (2000)
Synopsis: Virginia and her father Tony, living in Manhattan, find themselves in a parallel universe where fairy tale characters like Snow White, Cinderella, and Little Red Riding Hood are struggling to maintain order in their kingdoms, now disrupted by trolls, giants, and goblins.
Why Watch: It’s a fun blend of romance and fairy tales, especially the sweet romance between Virginia and Wolf (who is half-human, half-wolf).
Content Note: Not rated, but feels like TV-PG for language and some tense situations.
2. A Ghost Story (2017)
Synopsis: A recently deceased, sheet-covered ghost returns home to connect with his grieving wife in this contemplative exploration of time, love, and the search for meaning.
Why Watch: It’s slow-paced but perfect for those who enjoy artsy paranormal romances.
Content Note: Rated R for brief language and a disturbing image.
3. A Gifted Man (2011)
Synopsis: This drama centers around a brilliant surgeon whose life changes when his deceased ex-wife starts teaching him about the meaning of life from beyond the grave.
Why Watch: Patrick Wilson and Jennifer Ehle star, although the primary romance develops between Wilson’s character and another living doctor.
Content Note: TV-PG
4. Awaken (2012)
Synopsis: Alex and Rachel’s otherwise perfect relationship faces a unique hurdle—Rachel has recently passed away.
Why Watch: While I haven’t seen this, its trailer suggests a touching romance about dreams.
Content Note: Not rated; content unclear.
5. Battlestar Galactica (2004)
Synopsis: Survivors of a nuclear attack by robot Cylons, led by Commander Adama and President Roslin, seek a new home while pursued by their deadly enemies.
Why Watch: One of the best shows ever, it merges sci-fi with paranormal romance elements, including human-angel romances and Cylon/human relationships.
Content Note: TV-14 for violence, language, and sexuality.
6. Beastly (2011)
Synopsis: Kyle, a shallow high school student, is cursed by a witch to become as unattractive outside as he is inside. He has a year to find someone who will love him despite his appearance.
Why Watch: It’s a fun and modern take on the Beauty and the Beast story.
Content Note: PG-13 for language and brief violence.
7. Beautiful Accident (2017)
Synopsis: Due to an error in the afterlife, a high-powered lawyer must live another week in the body of a housewife.
Why Watch: If you enjoyed Drop Dead Diva, this Chinese film might be up your alley.
Content Note: Not rated; content unclear.
8. Beauty and the Beast (1987)
Synopsis: Assistant District Attorney Catherine Chandler learns she has a protector—Vincent, a kind-hearted beast living in tunnels beneath the city.
Why Watch: A modern and urban retelling of Beauty and the Beast, featuring an amazing performance from Ron Perlman.
Content Note: Not rated, usually TV-PG or TV-14.
9. Being Erica (2009)
Synopsis: After a series of mishaps, Erica meets the mysterious Dr. Tom who offers her a chance to fix her life by revisiting her past.
Why Watch: Known for its strong writing and characterization, the time travel romance between Erica and Kai steals the show.
Content Note: TV-PG on Amazon, but some episodes might be TV-14 or even TV-MA for language and sexuality.
10. Being Human UK (2009)
Synopsis: Vampire, werewolf, and ghost friends share a house and face the challenges of their supernatural lives while bonding over their desire to be human.
Why Watch: A beautifully written series starring Aidan Turner as a Byronic vampire with a heartbreakingly romantic storyline with a ghost named Annie.
Content Note: Depending on the episode, could be TV-14 or TV-MA for language, violence, and sexuality.
11. Beyond Tomorrow (1940)
Synopsis: Three wealthy old friends, now ghosts, try to bring a young couple together during Christmas.
Why Watch: A sentimental holiday classic perfect for fans of old Christmas movies.
Content Note: TV-G
12. BrainDead (2016)
Synopsis: This comic-thriller set in Washington, D.C., follows Laurel as she discovers that bugs are eating the brains of Congress members.
Why Watch: Hilarious satire with fantastic romantic chemistry between Laurel and Gareth.
Content Note: TV-14 for violence, language, and sensuality.
13. Dark Shadows (1966)
Synopsis: A daytime series filled with gothic mystery and supernatural intrigue, revolving around the guilt-ridden vampire, Barnabas Collins.
Why Watch: A classic vampire show with romantic elements.
Content Note: TV-PG
14. Dead Again (1991)
Synopsis: An amnesia victim’s nightmares lead a detective to uncover their connection to a past life filled with romance and murder.
Why Watch: A romantic murder mystery about reincarnation starring Kenneth Branagh and Emma Thompson.
Content Note: Rated R for violence, sensuality, and strong language.
15. Detective Anna (2016)
Synopsis: In 19th-century Russia, young Anna discovers she can communicate with the dead, using her visions to solve crimes.
Why Watch: This Russian series sounds captivating, combining supernatural elements with romance.
Content Note: Not rated; content unclear.
16. Doctor Who (2005)
Synopsis (Season 1): Rose meets the Doctor, an alien with a time-traveling machine, and together they embark on fantastic adventures.
Why Watch: Known for its blend of paranormal romance and urban fantasy, especially the epic romance between the Doctor and Rose.
Content Note: TV-PG
17. Down to Earth (1947)
Synopsis: The Greek Muse of Dance, Terpsichore, heads to Earth to stop a Broadway producer from trivializing her image, but ends up falling for him.
Why Watch: A unique classic musical starring the marvelous Rita Hayworth.
Content Note: G
18. Ghost Town (2008)
Synopsis: A dentist gains the ability to see and interact with ghosts, leading to unexpected romantic and comedic encounters.
Why Watch: A light-hearted, funny romantic comedy.
Content Note: PG-13 for strong language, drug references, and sexual humor.
19. Ghost Whisperer (2005)
Synopsis: Melinda Gordon can see and communicate with spirits who seek her help in resolving unfinished business.
Why Watch: An engaging urban fantasy series worth checking out.
Content Note: TV-PG
20. Grimm (2011)
Synopsis: Homicide Detective Nick Burkhardt discovers he is a Grimm, tasked with keeping the balance between humanity and mythological creatures.
Why Watch: One of the best urban fantasy series, filled with mythological creatures and gripping storylines.
Content Note: TV-14 for violence, language, and mild sexuality.
21. Highlander (1992)
Synopsis: Scotsman Duncan MacLeod, an immortal, navigates centuries-old battles between good and evil immortals, culminating in The Gathering.
Why Watch: It’s about an immortal Scotsman, which is reason enough!
Content Note: TV-14
22. H2O: Just Add Water (2006)
Synopsis: Three teenage girls transform into mermaids with extraordinary powers after discovering an ancient cavern.
Why Watch: A charming teen series with adorable mermaid adventures and some young romance.
Content Note: TV-PG
23. I Am Dragon (2015)
Synopsis: Princess Miroslava is kidnapped by a dragon on her wedding day and develops a complicated relationship with a mysterious young man.
Why Watch: This Russian film features a unique dragon-human romance.
Content Note: Not rated. Contains slight rear nudity and dark themes of sacrifice.
24. Il Mare (2000)
Synopsis: A man and a woman living two years apart communicate and develop a romantic connection through a mysterious mailbox.
Why Watch: If you enjoyed The Lake House, you’ll love this original Korean film.
Content Note: PG
25. The Last Keepers (2013)
Synopsis: A teenage girl from a family of reclusive artists discovers she has mysterious powers and unravels family secrets after falling for an unusual boy.
Why Watch: A fun movie about witches with a great cast.
Content Note: PG-13 for language, disturbing images, and teen drinking.
For the rest of the best paranormal romance movies and TV shows on Amazon Prime, continue to the next part of the list.
