The Turn of the Screw (2009) BBC Review
This review contains spoilers!
I generally love period dramas, but some just don’t usually grab my interest. Nevertheless, I decided to give this one a shot because one of its actors is a favorite of mine. This period drama is an adaptation of Henry James’ “The Turn of the Screw,” a Gothic story that really makes you question everybody involved.
The story starts with our main character, Ann (played by Michelle Dockery), sitting in an asylum. She looks worn out and lifeless. At the hospital, Dr. Fisher (Dan Stevens) is curious and believes he can help her, but only if she tells him what happened at Bly, the country estate where she took care of two young children.
Ann gradually starts to share her experiences at Bly. She talks about strange events and mysterious staff, led by the housekeeper Sarah (Sue Johnston), all leading to a tragic end.
Written by Henry James in 1868, this novella originally appeared as a serial in Colliers Weekly Magazine. James, also known for “The Portrait of a Lady” and “The Wings of the Dove,” crafted an intriguing ghost story. Although it’s been adapted for the screen before, this was my first time experiencing the story in any form. The concept is fascinating, but the adaptation doesn’t quite develop fully and isn’t exactly a feel-good story.
The script, managed by Sandy Welch who you might know from BBC’s “Emma” and “Jane Eyre,” runs only 88 minutes. With such a short duration, the story moves quickly with little room for deeper exploration. Surprisingly, it does feel somewhat complete. Through Ann’s narrative, we learn what happened at Bly, but like many ghost stories, much is left to interpretation. Is Ann mad, or is there genuinely something sinister afflicting her and the children?
What I appreciate most about this production, other than the cast, is the contrast between dark and light. The story is filled with dark undertones and subtle, rather than overt, frightening elements. This is partly due to the beautiful scenery, summer setting, and white muslin costumes. Bly is a decaying mansion, yet the lovely outdoor scenes and picnics give it an idyllic appearance.
The cast adds to this cheerful illusion. For fans of “Downton Abbey” like me, seeing Dan and Michelle in roles drastically different from their beloved characters, Matthew and Mary, is delightful. Both deliver outstanding performances, as does the rest of the cast. While the story isn’t a cheerful one, leaving us feeling uneasy, it might be perfect for those who enjoy Gothic tales without the terrifying components.
Where to Watch: You can watch “The Turn of the Screw” on Amazon Prime. It is also available for rent or purchase on Digital and DVD.
Content Note: The film features around 3-4 brief sex scenes with some nudity. There are also tense moments and suggestions of depravity in the household. One character commits suicide, and her bloody body is shown. The film is rated TV-14.
