I recently stumbled upon a gem of a movie called “Deep Valley” on Turner Classic Movies. This romantic crime drama, featuring Ida Lupino, Dane Clark, and Wayne Morris, is a captivating blend of romance, suspense, and sheer emotion.
For those who may not know, Ida Lupino was a trailblazer in the film industry. She was the first woman to direct a film noir in 1953 and the only female producer and director in the 1950s. She was incredibly talented, excelling as a writer, director, producer, and actress. In “Deep Valley,” she shines as a naive woman with a stuttering problem who falls in love with an escaped convict.
The Story
Libby Saul is a poor woman mistreated by her constantly feuding parents. Her life is isolated and lonely, with her only companion being a dog. That changes when convicts arrive to build a new road near her home. She becomes intrigued by Barry, a convict working on the road. When a disaster kills most of the men, Barry escapes and finds refuge in Libby’s secret hideout in the woods. The two fall in love, despite Barry’s violent past. But their happiness is threatened by the constant danger of being caught.
Deep Valley (1947) – The Review
“Deep Valley” is a unique mix of crime drama, romance, and melodrama. It deeply respects nature and carries an optimistic view of redemption. Watching the film, one might feel suspicious of Barry. Does he genuinely love Libby, or is he manipulating her? Libby, having never known true happiness because of her abusive parents, is consumed by newfound feelings of love and joy with Barry. She even overcomes her stutter and begins to stand up for herself.
However, Barry’s violent tendencies make viewers wary. We are torn between rooting for their relationship and hoping Libby sees that Barry may not be the best choice. This film is best enjoyed without applying a modern perspective.
Romance
Despite the leading man’s questionable behavior, the romance in “Deep Valley” shares the wild, captivating passion of “Wuthering Heights.” The chemistry between the actors is incredible, making the romance intriguing even if it’s not entirely healthy. Ida Lupino and Dane Clark deliver strong performances, bringing believability to their characters and balancing the film’s melodramatic elements.
The Crew
The film benefits from the exceptional talent behind the scenes. Directed by Jean Negulesco (Oscar-nominated for “Johnny Belinda”), it features top-notch screenwriters like Salka Viertel and Stephen Morehouse Avery, with some uncredited input from the renowned author William Faulkner. The cinematography beautifully captures Libby’s isolation, and the production design is noteworthy.
While the film may feel slow at times, especially in the beginning, it builds to a suspenseful climax that keeps you engaged.
Overall
If you appreciate the sweeping romanticism found in stories like “Wuthering Heights,” you’ll likely enjoy “Deep Valley.” In addition to showcasing Ida Lupino’s underrated talent, the film boasts an excellent script and wonderful direction. It’s a story steeped in deep emotion, nature, and soul connections. However, it’s not an example of an ideal, healthy love story.
“Deep Valley” is available on DVD and occasionally airs on TCM. It’s rated NR but would likely be considered PG for mild violence and suspense.
Have you seen “Deep Valley”? Are you interested in it? Share your thoughts on this classic romance in the comments!
