Will Falling in Love Reveal Her Past? A Look at Eva Ibbotson’s “A Countess Below Stairs”
A Countess Below Stairs: An Overview
After the Russian Revolution turns her life upside down, Anna, a young Russian countess, is forced to flee to England. Now penniless, she conceals her noble heritage and takes a job as a servant in the prestigious Westerholme family household. Armed with only an old housekeeping manual and her determination, she dives into her new role.
Trying to keep her past hidden, Anna struggles with her duties and finds herself instantly attracted to Rupert, the charming Earl of Westerholme. To complicate things, Rupert seems to be falling for her too. As their feelings grow, Anna finds it increasingly difficult to keep her secrets. Adding to the drama is Rupert’s beautiful but malicious fiancée.
Book Review: “A Countess Below Stairs” by Eva Ibbotson
If you enjoy sweet fairy tales and were a fan of “Downton Abbey,” Eva Ibbotson’s historical romance “A Countess Below Stairs” might just be your next favorite read. Also known as “The Secret Countess,” the story revolves around Anna Grazinsky, a refugee from war-torn Russia, who finds herself in England after losing her previous life of splendor and privilege. Once used to dancing in grand ballrooms and wearing lavish jewels, Anna now blends into the background as one of the household servants. But blending in has never been Anna’s style.
A Cinderella-Like Story
Anna’s father is dead, their home has been plundered, and the family jewels are lost, possibly stolen by the very servant who was supposed to smuggle them out. Anna, her mother, her younger brother, and her English governess arrive in post-WWI London with little to their name. While her governess, Miss Pinfold, has some savings, they were not meant to support four people. Sparing her younger brother Peter the harshness of their situation, he is sent to a good boarding school. To help with his education and lessen the burden on Miss Pinfold, Anna takes up a job in domestic service.
Desperate for help, the butler and housekeeper at Mersham, the elaborate estate of the Earl of Westerholme, hire Anna. Though inexperienced, she is enthusiastic and determined. It’s a temporary position, meant to last until the new earl and his fiancée arrive. The new earl, Rupert, is a second son who became the heir after his elder brother died in the war. Having spent months recovering from his own war injuries, Rupert is haunted by his experiences.
Rupert met his fiancée, Muriel, when she was his nurse. Apprehensive about his new responsibilities and the estate’s financial woes, Rupert considers his relationship with the wealthy and parentless Muriel a blessing. But then there’s Anna, the sincere and kind servant girl who charms everyone, including the earl’s dog. Unlike Muriel, who gradually reveals her coldness and unsettling beliefs about eugenics, Anna radiates compassion, humility, and goodness.
Frothy, Fun, and Full of Heart
While “A Countess Below Stairs” may appear to be a simple fairy tale, Ibbotson’s skillful writing, wit, and attention to detail elevate it to something special. Despite its backdrop of significant loss, upheaval, and rising intolerance, the story remains fun and lighthearted, demonstrating Ibbotson’s ability to balance various tones. Her nuanced storytelling makes the book a compelling read.
One particular scene stands out: Rupert returns to his old haunts at Cambridge, reminiscing about friends lost in battle. This poignant moment adds depth to the otherwise lighthearted narrative. The book is full of these moments, providing a rich, multifaceted experience.
The ending playfully nods to Jane Eyre, leaving you smiling and filled with hope. “A Countess Below Stairs” is a delightful read, deceptively cheerful with underlying depth. It’s a book I could see myself rereading; it has quickly become a new favorite.
Final Thoughts
Eva Ibbotson’s “A Countess Below Stairs” is a marvel of storytelling, blending fairy tale elements with historical drama and romance. It’s a book that leaves you hopeful and eager to see it adapted onscreen one day.
