TV Series Review: Always a Witch (2019)
Always a Witch is a contemporary Colombian young adult fantasy drama available on Netflix. The series is inspired by the book Yo, Bruja by Isidora Chacon. It follows Carmen, a 17th-century slave and witch, who travels to the 21st century on a mission that impacts the past, present, and future. Carmen’s journey in the modern world is driven by her desire to save the man she loves.
The show features a strong ensemble cast with Carmen, played by the captivating Angely Gaviria, at its center. Carmen is a likable character, supported by a range of endearing characters, even if they follow some familiar stereotypes.
Set against the backdrop of parties and beaches, the show blends corny CGI with the narrative of a displaced witch. The plot alternates between historical and modern Cartagena, filled with both attractive and villainous figures.
From 1646 to 2019
In 17th-century Cartagena, Carmen is a slave with unique powers, inherited from her mother. Orphaned and owned by a wealthy Spanish family, she falls in love with their son, Cristobal. However, the era’s harsh realities of witch hunts and racial oppression doom their love. Accused of witchcraft and found guilty, Carmen faces execution. In prison, a warlock named Aldemar, trapped in time, offers a deal. If she travels to the future and helps him, he’ll aid her in saving Cristobal.
At the stake, Carmen uses Aldemar’s incantation and arrives in a future Cartagena where a serial killer is targeting women. She must find Aldemar’s contact, complete her mission, and return to her time to save Cristobal. However, the task proves challenging as her contact disappears, she faces a witch hunter, and struggles to navigate an unfamiliar world and fulfill Aldemar’s request.
Carmen enrolls at a university, makes friends, and learns to adapt, but frequently loses her powers. She must rely on new allies and share her secrets to succeed.
A Magical Mess
Always a Witch has several logical leaps and time travel inconsistencies. The implications of bringing modern technology like an iPhone into the 17th century are overlooked. The love interests feel forced, and the emerging love triangle is poorly developed. Carmen’s magic lacks consistency, adding to the confusion about how it works.
Despite these issues, the show offers some enjoyable aspects. The unique angle of bringing someone from the past to the present is refreshing, even if its consequences are not fully explored. The connection between Carmen and Cristobal, who communicate across time with letters, adds a magical and romantic touch.
The show has its charming elements, attractive characters, and entertaining plots, making it a light, enjoyable watch. I look forward to season 2.
Content Note: Rated TV-14 for drinking, mild swearing, and thematic material. Available on Netflix.
