Effie Gray Review
Effie Gray is a remarkable period drama written by Emma Thompson and directed by Richard Laxton. Emma Thompson, well-known for her Academy Award-winning adaptation of Sense and Sensibility, brings her first original screenplay to life with this film. Directed by BAFTA-nominated Richard Laxton, Effie Gray stands out as one of the finest period dramas of recent years.
The movie stars Dakota Fanning, who delivers a radiant and heartfelt portrayal of Effie Gray, a woman who defied Victorian societal norms and sparked a scandal that still resonates today. The cast is filled with exceptional talent including Emma Thompson, Greg Wise, Tom Sturridge, Julie Walters, David Suchet, Derek Jacobi, James Fox, Robbie Coltrane, and Russell Tovey. The production team also features accomplished professionals like Ruth Myers, known for costume design in films like Nicholas Nickleby and The Painted Veil, and Andrew Dunn, the cinematographer of Gosford Park. James Merifield, the production designer of Little Dorrit, also lends his expertise to the film.
The story centers on Euphemia “Effie” Gray and her tumultuous marriage to John Ruskin, a renowned critic played by Greg Wise. Effie had known Ruskin since childhood, and he even wrote her a fairy tale when she was just 12. They married when she was 19, but Ruskin refused to consummate the marriage for unclear reasons. This rejection left Effie increasingly isolated, anxious, and depressed. Ruskin’s controlling mother, brilliantly portrayed by Julie Walters, further compounded her distress.
Effie finds solace and support in Lady Elizabeth Eastlake, played by Emma Thompson, while also forging a deep connection with John Everett Millais, portrayed by Tom Sturridge. Millais, an emerging artist and one of the founders of the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood, is painting Ruskin’s portrait. Effie and Millais fall in love, though they do not act on their feelings. Millais becomes increasingly distraught over Ruskin’s cruel treatment of Effie, especially as her health visibly deteriorates. Eventually, Effie decides to challenge societal norms to reclaim her freedom.
While there is no concrete evidence about the exact nature of Effie and Ruskin’s relationship, historical records suggest that Ruskin may have been repulsed by Effie’s physical form, likely because he had idealized classical statues. The film subtly implies that Ruskin’s obsession with these unrealistic standards contributed to his disdain for Effie.
Throughout their marriage, Effie claimed that Ruskin offered various reasons for refusing to be intimate, such as religious motives and a desire to preserve her beauty. Eventually, Ruskin admitted that he was disgusted by her appearance, further invalidating her as a wife and partner.
John Everett Millais, in correspondence with Effie’s mother, revealed his frustration with Ruskin, describing his inexcusable behavior and indifference toward Effie. Effie’s plight reflects the oppressive standards and the emotional abuses that women often faced during that period.
In the film, Thompson subtly hints that Ruskin might have been attracted to younger girls, drawing eerie parallels through his interactions with Effie’s younger sister and his subsequent affection for Rose La Touche, who was only ten when Ruskin developed feelings for her. This adds another layer of complexity to Ruskin’s character, suggesting an uncomfortable and possibly inappropriate fixation.
Effie Gray not only highlights the main characters’ experiences but also uses visual storytelling to enhance the narrative. Millais’ painting “Ophelia” is repeatedly referenced to illustrate Effie’s emotional turmoil. The film intertwines themes of fairy tales and historical drama, portraying Effie as a princess who must overcome adversities to find her happiness.
Despite a few criticisms, such as the decision not to have Dakota Fanning adopt a Scottish accent, her performance remains powerful and effective in conveying Effie’s emotional journey. Effie Gray’s story is presented primarily from her perspective, making her the central figure and emphasizing her struggle and triumph.
For fans of historical period dramas, art history, and literature, Effie Gray is a must-watch. It may be slower-paced for those expecting action, but its compelling narrative and strong performances make it a standout. Though Effie’s theory might differ from historical facts, the film offers a captivating interpretation of her life.
Effie Gray can be purchased on DVD, though it may not be compatible with all U.S. DVD players. If you can find a way to watch it, it’s highly recommended.
Content Note: The film is rated PG-13 and includes some sexual situations.
