Darcy and Elizabeth
We can’t be the only ones indulging in Buzzfeed quizzes circulating on social media, such as “Which Jane Austen Heroine Are You?” or “Which Disney Prince is Your True Love?”. These quizzes are undeniably fun and spark curiosity about which fictional characters we resemble, be it from TV shows or classic novels. Often, our favorite characters resonate most when we see a bit of ourselves in them. However, none of us can truly be Elizabeth Bennet, regardless of how deeply we relate to her or wish to embody her character traits.
So, what’s the point of this discussion? Well, as part of the Silver Petticoat Review team, we thought it would be entertaining to conduct a little experiment. Each of us picked characters we believe we resemble and explained why. To ensure an unbiased approach, we also asked our friends and family for their perspectives on who they think we are like. We encourage all of you to join in and share which characters you identify with, even seeking input from friends and family for some amusing and enlightening responses. Let’s dive into the details with Amber:
How Amber Sees Herself:
Sara Stanley from Road to Avonlea:
Although I’m quite similar to Anne Shirley, I identify more with Sara. She’s dreamy and optimistic but grounded in reality. As a child, I was a storyteller, putting on plays and even being a bit of a tomboy. Sara’s curiosity about adults and their stories mirrors my own. Growing up in idyllic Maine in the ’90s was quite similar to Sara’s childhood on Prince Edward Island with the King children.
Jane Austen in Becoming Jane:
I relate to Jane’s love for writing, her pride, and her witty, sometimes snarky nature. Much like Jane, I dislike being artistically insulted and can react strongly. Similar to her walk past the grand house to avoid a setup, I too would only marry for love, stubbornness prevailing over societal expectations.
Margaret Hale from North & South:
Compassionate yet stubborn, I would likely react similarly to Margaret if confronted with unjust treatment of others. I would take time to understand and support the underprivileged, driven by a deep sense of empathy, much like Margaret. John Thornton’s character, with his passion and intellect, aligns with my ideal type.
Lorelai Gilmore from Gilmore Girls:
Our personalities align closely, especially in the way Lorelai talks, mixing pop culture references with rapid, animated conversations. We share similar interests like movies, board games, and dancing. I’m also sentimental about houses and enjoy intellectual debates, though I was less rebellious as a teenager.
Amanda Woods in The Holiday:
Not being a crier, I laughed at Amanda’s attempts to force tears, something I’ve tried too. While deeply emotional inwardly, I rarely show it. More into kickboxing than yoga, I share Amanda’s intense project focus and need for a holiday.
How Others See Amber:
Autumn (Twin Sister):
Jane Austen in Becoming Jane – Apparently, she feels Jane epitomizes me.
Mom:
Anne Shirley from Anne of Green Gables – Imaginative, prideful, and competitive, much like Anne, I had a temper and thirst for proving people wrong during my school days.
Stepdad:
Emily Montgomery from In & Out – A humorous take, suggesting I’d react similarly if put through significant emotional distress.
Rebecca (Friend):
Dana Scully from The X-Files – Known for logical thinking and maintaining emotional composure, aligning well with my temperament.
Aunt Scarlett:
Anne Shirley and Buffy the Vampire Slayer – Apparently, my assertive side and my tomboyish childhood resonate with these characters.
Aunt Dolly:
Rose from Titanic – Feisty and passionate, with a love for artistic pursuits and a disdain for being controlled.
How Autumn Sees Herself:
Fanny Price in Mansfield Park (1999 adaptation):
Shy, loyal, and moralistic, I resonate with Fanny’s introspection, intuitive skepticism of dubious characters, and passion for writing.
Emily Byrd Starr from L.M. Montgomery’s Emily books:
A kindred spirit with a strong imagination and writing passion, Emily’s pride and seriousness mirror my own characteristics.
Evelyn Carnahan from The Mummy:
Clumsy yet knowledgeable, my librarian pursuits and quest for adventure match well with Evelyn, minus the mummy encounters.
Felicity Porter from Felicity:
Shy, neurotic, and studious, much like Felicity, I pursued English and writing despite external doubts, with a penchant for intense introspection.
Hermione Granger from Harry Potter:
Overachieving, bossy, and a lover of research, I relate deeply to Hermione’s fear of failure and compulsion to fight for what’s right.
How Others See Autumn:
Amber (Twin Sister):
Fanny Price and Ada Monroe from Cold Mountain – Agreeing on Fanny, Amber added Ada for my survival instincts and need for help in dire situations.
Rebecca (Friend):
Hermione Granger – Acknowledging my bossiness and overachievement, fitting well with Hermione’s traits.
Mom and Stepfather:
Snow White – A whimsical image of me singing and caring for others, reflective of my nurturing side.
Brother Aaron:
Danielle from Ever After – Romantic, bookish, and passionate about justice, aligning with my personality.
Aunt Dolly:
Scully from The X-Files – Reserved and logical, with a touch of emotional secrecy.
Aunt Scarlett:
Elizabeth Wakefield and Marian the Librarian – Studious, twin identity, and literary passion combine these two characters for her.
How Rebecca Sees Herself:
Rory Gilmore:
Quiet, studious, and focused, my journey mirrors Rory’s academic excellence and clear life goals.
Jane Hayes from Austenland:
A lover of fantasy and romance, I identify with Jane’s deep immersion in bookish dreams.
Rapunzel from Tangled:
A dreamer at heart, constantly envisioning the world outside and my place within it.
Belle from Once Upon a Time:
My love for books and seeing the best in people aligns closely with Belle’s character.
Katie Nic Aoidh from The Decoy Bride:
Writing as a sanctuary, my awkwardness, and preference for solitude resonate with Katie’s quirky island life.
How Others See Rebecca:
Autumn and Amber:
Catherine Morland and Alice – Dreamers lost in fantasy worlds, much like myself.
Brother and His Girlfriend:
Bastian from The Neverending Story and Andie from The Devil Wears Prada – Bookish escapism and a writer’s journey through New York.
Mom:
Little Red Riding Hood – Navigating life’s challenges with innocence and resilience.
Dad:
Bubbles from The Powerpuff Girls – Cute and bubbly personality traits identified by my father.
Who Rebecca Wishes She Was Like:
Sabriel from The Abhorsen Series by Garth Nix:
Calm, collected, and powerful, Sabriel embodies the composed and confident qualities I aspire to.
Now It’s Your Turn!
What fictional characters do you think you resemble? Share your thoughts in the comments.
