The Beauty and the Beast: A Tale for the Ages
The story of Beauty and the Beast is timeless, tracing back from myths like Cupid and Psyche to Gabrielle-Suzanne Barbot de Villeneuve’s original 1740 novel, and Jeanne-Marie Leprince de Beaumont’s popular abridged version. Over the years, it has evolved through various adaptations in movies, TV shows, and books.
As fans of this classic tale, we decided to rank the best and most popular movie and TV adaptations from worst to best. Note that this is not an exhaustive list, as we’ve excluded films that merely use the themes of Beauty and the Beast. Instead, these picks are direct adaptations or close retellings.
Ranking the Best Beauty and the Beast Adaptations
16. Beastly (2011)
Starring Alex Pettyfer and Vanessa Hudgens, “Beastly” targets a teen audience with its modern take. A spoiled New York teen is cursed by a witch to become “ugly,” needing true love to break the spell. Though the film could delve deeper into its themes, it remains a fun, light-hearted watch.
15. Beauty and the Beast (1987)
This 1987 musical adaptation from the Cannon Movie Tales series is a family favorite. While it can be a bit melodramatic, and the songs aren’t particularly notable, it maintains a sweet charm.
14. The Beautician and the Beast (1997)
Fans of “The Nanny” might enjoy this romantic comedy spoof where a New York cosmetologist ends up working for a “beastly” Eastern European dictator. It’s an enjoyable film, especially for Fran Drescher and Timothy Dalton enthusiasts.
13. Beauty and the Beast TV Series (2012-2016)
This urban fantasy series tells the story of a detective who falls for a man transformed into a beast through a government experiment. Despite ups and downs in the show and changes in showrunners, the chemistry between Jay Ryan and Kristin Kreuk is undeniable.
12. Once Upon a Time: Rumple and Belle (2011-2018)
Rumple and Belle from “Once Upon a Time” are a beloved TV couple. Their story takes inspiration from the Disney version while adding unique twists. Although it’s not a perfect adaptation, their romance, especially in the episode “Skin Deep,” offers a fresh take on the classic tale.
11. Faerie Tale Theatre: Beauty and the Beast (1984)
Part of the ’80s series by Shelley Duvall, this episode features Susan Sarandon and Klaus Kinski in a homage to the 1946 Cocteau film. Though not unique, it captures the essence of the original classic with added charm from Anjelica Huston.
10. Beauty and the Beast (1976)
The Hallmark Hall of Fame TV movie stars George C. Scott and his real-life wife, Trish Van Devere. It was nominated for three Emmys and stands out for its Romanticism and emotional depth, though the beast looks quite different from the usual depiction.
9. Beauty and the Beast (2017)
Featuring Emma Watson and Dan Stevens, this Disney remake is visually stunning with strong supporting characters. Despite some flaws like excessive CGI and lack of chemistry between the leads, the high production quality and memorable music make it a good adaptation.
8. The Scarlet Flower (1952 & 1978)
These Russian adaptations tell the story of a young woman who falls in love with an enchanted prince. The 1952 version, in particular, is recognized for its vibrant colors and beautiful animation.
7. Penelope (2006)
In this gender-bender version, a young woman cursed with a pig nose must learn to love herself to break the spell. Featuring James McAvoy and Christina Ricci, this heartwarming film is full of romantic moments and a soulful message about self-acceptance.
6. Beauty and the Beast TV Series (1987-1990)
Starring Ron Perlman and Linda Hamilton, this romantic urban fantasy became a cult hit. The original series, about a beast living underground and a New York district attorney, remains the best adaptation despite newer versions.
5. Beauty and the Beast/La Belle et la Bete (2014)
This French version boasts gorgeous costumes and beast makeup, drawing more from the original Villeneuve book. Although a few unnecessary flashbacks detract from the film, its beauty and fresh take make it memorable.
4. Panna a Netvor/Beauty and the Beast (1978)
A Gothic horror adaptation from Czechoslovakia, this film portrays the beast as a deadly killer with a bird-like face. Despite its frightening elements, it’s a captivating adaptation with a standout performance by Vlastimil Harapes.
3. Jane Eyre Adaptations (1983, 2006, 2011)
Considered a retelling of Beauty and the Beast, “Jane Eyre” involves a young woman falling for a complex man. Various adaptations capture the essence of the tale, with notable ones in 1983, 2006, and 2011.
2. Beauty and the Beast (1991)
Disney’s animated classic is a magical and memorable adaptation of the tale, focusing on Beaumont’s version. It’s a timeless film that continues to enchant audiences.
1. La Belle et la Bete (1946)
Jean Cocteau’s 1946 film remains the gold standard for Beauty and the Beast adaptations. It’s an artistic, beautiful, and haunting rendition that has influenced countless versions since.
What’s your favorite version of Beauty and the Beast? Did we miss any of your favorites? Let us know!
