“Switched” Review
“Switched” by Amanda Hocking is a young adult novel set in modern times, and it’s the first book in the Trylle series. Amanda Hocking gained fame through self-publishing in 2010, and while she has published other novels since then, “Switched” remains one of her most well-known works. Readers on Goodreads generally consider her later books to be better, but that doesn’t mean “Switched” is bad.
The story follows Wendy, a girl who has never quite fit in. She’s difficult, awkward, and just different. When she was seven, her mother, in a fit of rage, tried to kill her, claiming she was a monster. Recently, Wendy has discovered she can make people do what she wants just by thinking about it. A mysterious boy takes a special interest in her and reveals that she isn’t human but a Trylle, a changeling. At first, Wendy thinks he’s crazy, but as she considers it more, it starts to make sense.
The novel starts with some clichés but becomes more intriguing as it delves into the world of the Trylle. The best parts are the folklore and world-building. It’s refreshing to read a young adult book about trolls instead of the usual fairies, and the concept of modern-day changelings is handled uniquely.
The main character, Wendy, isn’t particularly likable, but the supporting characters are well-developed and feel real. The romance element felt somewhat forced, with Wendy and Finn’s connection developing too quickly and without much chemistry. However, Wendy’s interactions with another character show more promise, which could be explored in future books. The Trylle society’s pressures on Wendy and Finn’s relationship add a realistic obstacle that isn’t easily overcome.
The mystery of Wendy’s true identity could have been built up more, and the pacing is uneven. After Finn reveals the truth, things move quickly and then slow down for the rest of the book. The ending is sudden and open-ended, clearly setting up for the next book but lacking enough resolution.
The writing is clear and easy to read, and Hocking does a good job of making the reader feel present in the story. Despite some issues, “Switched” is an enjoyable read for mid to late teens, though it may not appeal to more mature readers.
Adaptation Recommendation
The film rights to the Trylle series have been bought and reverted back to the author, so a movie might not be coming soon. With its structure, the book would work better as a feature-length film or a web series rather than a traditional series. Casting ideas include Chloe Moretz or Danielle Campbell as Wendy and Andrew Garfield or Ed Westwick as Finn. Madeleine Stowe would be ideal for Elora, the beautiful, cold Queen of the Trylle. A movie adaptation could be exciting if it adds more mystery and reworks the pacing, especially with actors who have good chemistry.
Content Note: Profanity is present but not pervasive. Some scenes involve fighting without gore, and a character briefly mentions being stabbed and needing stitches. There’s no sex or sexual contact beyond passionate kissing, and no nudity.
