BBC’s adaptation of “North and South” is arguably one of the most romantic period dramas ever made. The gloomy skies of Milton serve as a backdrop to the passionate romance between Margaret Hale and John Thornton. Their chemistry is immediate and gradually evolves into a legendary love story. If you don’t believe me, just check out the North and South hashtags on Twitter or Tumblr—it’s a treasure trove!
I think it’s safe to say that John Thornton’s brooding nature contributes significantly to the allure of this romance. His very name evokes deep emotions—sighs of delight, groans of frustration, and heartache at his declarations of love.
John Thornton has countless unforgettable moments throughout “North and South.” His romantic intensity, boorish traits, and glimpses of vulnerability make him a lasting character.
Here are 15 memorable John Thornton scenes from “North and South” that stay with you long after you watch them. This list is subjective, but I think many will agree with at least a few. Honestly, any list featuring John Thornton is worth taking the time to read.
15 MOST MEMORABLE JOHN THORNTON SCENES
(From “North and South” in Chronological Order)
1 John Thornton Makes His Entrance
It’s just a brief moment when Margaret first sees John Thornton in the sorting room. Despite his stern expression, there’s something captivating about him—until he starts yelling, of course.
2 I Made a Terrible First Impression…My Second Won’t Be Any Better
During their first formal meeting, there’s instant attraction despite their differences. John is harsh and defensive, but as he leaves, he gives Margaret one last thoughtful look.
3 The Tea was in No Danger of Going Cold
One of the most romantic scenes is when John intensely watches Margaret pour him tea. His slight, almost secretive smile is incredibly seductive.
4 When John Thornton Hung on Margaret’s Every Word
Many of their conversations turn into arguments, but this one is different. They passionately debate their viewpoints with a newfound respect for each other.
5 Please Like Margaret Because I Think I Love Her, Okay?
This touching moment reveals John’s vulnerable side. He quietly asks his mother to try to like Margaret, showing his feelings are changing. His wistful look when he realizes Margaret may never want him is heartbreaking.
6 Shaking Hands…and Flirting…the Milton Way
John takes several steps forward in this moment, smiling down at Margaret after she shakes his hand. Her composure is admirable; many would have melted on the spot!
7 You Are So Worthy, John Thornton
Here we see all of John’s self-doubt and yearning. Despite knowing his feelings, he’s convinced Margaret doesn’t feel the same way. This scene contrasts sharply with his usual confident demeanor.
8 Swoon-worthy Love Confession
John’s passionate declaration of love is honest and raw, filled with outrage and disbelief at Margaret’s accusations. This unforgettable moment was best captured in a video.
9 A Mother’s Love
Some of John’s most memorable scenes are with his mother. Their strong relationship is evident when he tells her Margaret doesn’t want him, feeling he isn’t good enough.
10 John Thornton Plans Henry’s Funeral
John’s intense jealousy when he thinks of Henry is palpable, showing he’s still deeply in love with Margaret.
11 When All of Us Shook Our Heads at John Thornton
John often misinterprets Margaret’s actions and intentions, especially in scenes filled with jealousy that practically reaches out and grabs you.
12 John Thornton Breaking Our Hearts
The scene where John watches Margaret leave is full of anguish. His whispered plea for her to look back and his intense gaze as she departs is truly heart-wrenching.
13 Memories…
John revisits the sorting room, reflecting on the business he lost and the first time he saw Margaret there. The place holds special meaning for him, showcasing his romantic nature.
14 Clarity after Jealousy
John’s expression when he learns the man at the train station is Margaret’s brother is priceless. Despite his financial troubles, he looks relieved, as if a burden has been lifted.
15 John Thornton Smiles in Joy
The story culminates in a beautiful scene when John sees Margaret on the platform. Every expression on his face is swoon-worthy, marking the beginning of their life together.
These are just 15 of the most memorable and romantic John Thornton moments from “North and South.” Richard Armitage’s portrayal brings this complex character to life. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I need to watch this epic love story again.
Did we include your favorite John Thornton moment from “North and South”? What scenes would you add? Let me know! I’m always up for a chat about John Thornton!
