I went into the Emily movie with mixed feelings. Being a big fan of Emily Brontë, I was curious to see how this film would depict her life, especially with Frances O’Connor, known for her role in Mansfield Park, at the helm as both writer and director. With O’Connor’s experience in period dramas, I hoped she would bring something captivating to the screen. However, given that Emily Brontë is such a mystifying historical figure, I wondered how O’Connor would present her to modern audiences. To my relief, I thoroughly enjoyed the film, even with its historical inaccuracies.
Interestingly, O’Connor decides to step away from strict historical accuracy and instead crafts a romantic and allusive story reminiscent of Wuthering Heights, almost as if Emily Brontë herself wrote the screenplay. This approach takes viewers on an emotional journey through a transformative period in Emily’s life, highlighting her evolution into a rebellious and influential literary icon. The film features a talented cast, including Emma Mackey, Oliver Jackson-Cohen, Alexandra Dowling, Gemma Jones, and Fionn Whitehead. Its atmospheric nature leaves a lasting impression, despite being a work of historical fiction.
Even though O’Connor takes creative liberties with the historical details of Emily and her equally talented sisters, Charlotte and Anne, she successfully captures the spirit and drive that fueled Emily Brontë’s brief literary career. With haunting cinematography, compelling performances, and a robust narrative, the film deepened my connection to the author of the dark masterpiece Wuthering Heights.
Regarding the storyline, “Emily” reimagines Emily Brontë’s own Gothic tale that inspired her famous novel, “Wuthering Heights.” Battling the sorrow of her mother’s death, Emily’s struggle within the confines of her family life and her yearning for artistic and personal freedom lead her on a journey to channel her creativity into one of the greatest novels of all time. The film delves into Emily’s literary endeavors and her relationships with her siblings, notably her strained relationship with Charlotte and her complex yet close bond with Branwell. A significant portion of the movie also explores the romantic connection between the shy Emily and the kind curate, William Weightman.
While avoiding any hints of incest, the movie suggests that Branwell represents Heathcliff, and William Weightman represents Edgar Linton. The passionate relationship between Emily and William mirrors the relationship between Cathy and Heathcliff from the book. The film does not shy away from depicting the harsh realities of the Brontë family, showing their genius and their struggles with life and love. It offers a unique view into the raw creativity that shaped these extraordinary authors.
Frances O’Connor makes an impressive debut as a writer and director with this film, demonstrating her potential in these roles. The film’s visual language stands out, thanks to the skills of cinematographer Nanu Segal, production designer Steve Summersgill, and art director Jono Moles. The depiction of the moors and the tumultuous history of the Brontë sisters immerses viewers in their world. The lighting and costumes, designed by Michael O’Connor, also significantly contribute to the movie’s atmosphere, capturing both the rugged beauty of the English moors and the individuality of the characters.
The music by Abel Korzeniowski is a perfect fit, with its haunting melodies and atmospheric sounds enhancing Emily’s story. The film’s exceptional filmmaking and production quality, combined with Frances O’Connor’s fresh portrayal of Emily Brontë, result in a memorable experience for viewers, particularly fans of Gothic romance and Romanticism.
Emma Mackey shines in the role of Emily Brontë, delivering an intense performance that adds depth to the enigmatic writer. She carries the film with a commanding presence and likability, showcasing herself as a rising star. Oliver Jackson-Cohen excellently portrays Reverend William Weightman, capturing the character’s inner conflict and keeping the audience intrigued. The supporting cast, including Fionn Whitehead as Branwell, Alexandra Dowling as Charlotte, Amelia Gething as Anne, Adrian Dunbar as Patrick Brontë, and Gemma Jones as Aunt Branwell, all deliver stellar performances, bringing these historical figures to life.
As writer and director, Frances O’Connor succeeds in presenting strong character development and an engaging plot. Watching the film may inspire viewers to delve deeper into the real stories of these individuals.
One of the most captivating elements of the movie is the romantic storyline between Emily Brontë and William Weightman. Though historical research suggests a romance between Anne Brontë and Weightman, O’Connor explores the “what if” scenario involving Emily and William. Despite being more fan fiction than fact, their chemistry is undeniable, and their interactions convey a passionate and poignant connection.
O’Connor’s use of Gothic imagery, including a particularly memorable séance scene, brings a haunting and atmospheric quality to Emily’s romance with William. The breathtaking scenes of West Yorkshire amplify the emotions depicted, deepening the audience’s connection to the characters.
Overall, Emily is a beautiful and moving film. While some creative liberties regarding historical facts, particularly concerning Charlotte, may be bothersome, the film is not meant to be a history lesson. Instead, it pays tribute to Emily Brontë by telling her story in a style akin to Wuthering Heights. The film captures the rugged beauty of the Yorkshire moors and tells an imaginative tale, with excellent performances, particularly from Emma Mackey, who brings a quiet strength and vulnerability to Emily, making her feel like a real person rather than a distant historical figure.
Emily also portrays the darker aspects of Brontë’s life, including Branwell’s struggles with alcoholism and drug use. The film’s emphasis on the Romanticism in Brontë’s work captures the wild and passionate spirit of Wuthering Heights and the deep emotional connections in Emily’s life. It also highlights the challenges she faced as a woman in a male-dominated world.
I highly recommend Emily to fans of Romantic literature and those interested in Emily Brontë’s life and work. While it may not be historically accurate, it is a heartfelt tribute to an enigmatic author. Note that the movie is rated R for a couple of lovemaking scenes with nudity and some drug use.
